Pro Audio Technology Explains the Science Behind the Use of Multiple Subwoofers
Paul Hales of Pro Audio Technology explains the benefits of installing multiple subwoofers in an audio system.
At one time it was enough for a surround sound system to include a subwoofer. Today’s multichannel audio systems are, however, a completely different matter. Multiple subwoofers are becoming increasingly common in modern AV systems, and in many cases the use of multiple subwoofers offer legitimate reasons beyond the testosterone value they bring to a system’s performance.
Validating the installation of multiple subwoofers are a number of studies from an array of respected audio experts that agree that multiple subwoofers provide a realistic way to balance low frequencies within home spaces.
Reinforcing the science behind the practice and the aesthetic value, is the enhanced performance multiple subwoofers bring in terms of output and immersiveness with object-based surround content.
Breaking down the science and value that multiple subwoofers provide, Paul Hales, owner and product designer, Pro Audio Technology, explains why integrators should consider installing multiple subwoofers in their AV jobs.
Multiple Subwoofers Naturally Improve Bass Performance
Hales says a major benefit of employing multiple subwoofers is that they can help integrators mitigate certain standing wave modes to produce smoother bass.
By arranging the subs symmetrically opposite each other along one or more of the room’s centerlines—width, length and height—integrators can largely ‘cancel out’ certain modes to smoothen low-frequency playback in home environments.
Elaborating on the practice of using multiple subs, Hales says this approach to room design requires multiple subs placed symmetrically about the centerline of the room, with all subwoofers operating in positive absolute polarity. This will position the subs within standing wave “lobes” of opposite polarity, thereby minimizing energy transfer to those modes.
Hales emphasizes this alignment effectively cancels certain modes, and notes that because of this phenomenon Pro Audio Technology advises dealers to utilize this installation approach if possible.
“At Pro Audio Technology we like to install four subwoofers optimally, with two larger, higher-powered subs on or along the front wall where you are seeing the image. You want the most power to come from where the listener’s eyes and brain are telling them the sound is occurring, and at least two more subwoofers placed elsewhere in the room,” comments Hales.
“We can talk about an additional trick to optimally place the symmetrical subs so you achieve further standing wave attenuation and get some additional energy in the back of the room to create full-range envelopment.”
A typical two subwoofer installation that Hales says integrators could offer clients - if the space and architecture allows - is an in-wall installation where the first sub is placed at 25 percent of the room width from the right front wall, and 25 percent of the room height from the floor. He says integrators can then place the second sub symmetrically opposing the first along the length and height centerlines, on the back wall. This “25 percent symmetrical alignment” positions the subs at the nulls of the second order length and height axial modes, which minimizes energy transfer to those modes, and the symmetry around the centerlines will drive certain other modes in antiphase, as described earlier.
If four subwoofers are available, this “25 percent symmetrical alignment” can then be duplicated on the side walls of the room, attenuating width modes.
Hales admits that placing subwoofers 25 percent of room height away from the ceiling is not always possible or practical. In those instances, the subs can be placed at the wall-floor junctions, 25 percent in from the neighboring walls. Height modes will not be controlled, but it’s possible to control length and width modes using this positioning.
Object-based Surround Systems Definitely Benefit from Multiple Subwoofers
While videophiles obsess over 4K, refresh rates and high dynamic range (HDR), the audio side of the home entertainment market has focused on the singular sound advancement of immersive audio.
Sometimes called object-based surround sound because mix engineers describe the mixing process as the ability to place “objects” within any point of the soundstage, Dolby Labs has aggressively championed immersive audio.
Hales says that formats such as Dolby’s popular Atmos technology and DTS’ DTS:X format can absolutely benefit from the support of multiple subwoofers.
“Multiple subwoofers definitely complement object-based systems because they allow for more ‘distributed’ bass management. Object-based surround systems require more speakers in the room, and that in turn necessitates smaller speakers—It’s just often impractical to have many large speakers both from the physical and budgetary standpoints,” asserts Hales.
“Since the surround speakers tend to be smaller, having many—four or more—subwoofers allows for the bass to be distributed throughout the listening room and allows for more localized bass management of the small surround speakers. With the subs physically closer to the surround speakers, they better support them and the sound becomes more contiguous and full-range as a result.”
Hales says that regardless of the room environment, which are more diverse than ever before, multiple subwoofers enhance any listening space.
Underscoring the value of multiple subwoofers, he says that while not ideal, square room shapes that are used for daily home activities can be just as performance oriented as rectangular, dedicated theaters.
“Square rooms don’t affect the optimum number [of subwoofers], but they are horrible for standing waves,” he admits.
“Square rooms aren’t ideal because of the build up of standing waves. If the room dimensions are the same or very close in any of the three axial directions, then the standing waves occur at the same frequencies, building upon one another. [Ideally] you want to avoid whole dimensional ratios in a room. Staggered room dimensions will distribute the standing wave frequencies and eliminate the potential for any modes to ‘coincide’.”
The important takeaway regardless of the room shape, usage or environment, is that a well-designed system that includes multiple subwoofers can help to mitigate some traditional acoustical problems, while enhancing the listening experience he adds.
Multiple Subwoofers: It’s All About the Illusion
Boiling the advantages of multiple subwoofers down to something that’s much more relatable to the general public, Hales emphasizes that multiple subs in a system simply delivers a more realistic experience.
“For me personally, the biggest benefit of multiple subwoofer systems in object-based systems is the impression of ‘full-range’ sound all around you in the immersive sound field,” he adds.
“It just makes for a better illusion. At the PRO Experience Center, we use four subwoofers in a 23-channel system to create a very coherent, contiguous ‘hemisphere’ of sound over and around the listener. This makes watching movies or concerts with well-engineered immersive soundtracks, shockingly convincing. You no longer feel like you’re watching a flat image with speakers around you. You feel like you’re in the scene. Multiple subs, as previously mentioned, can also allow for control of some standing wave modes too, so greater low frequency smoothness can be achieved.”
Secure Your Free Pass to CEDIA EXPO 2019
Register before Sept. 2 to gain free access to the opening keynote, product training & education series as well as the show floor including Innovation Alley and much more. Don’t miss your chance. Sign up today.
Bob is an audio enthusiast who has written about consumer electronics for various publications within Massachusetts before joining the staff of CE Pro in 2000. Bob is THX Level I certified, and he's also taken classes from the Imaging Science Foundation (ISF) and Home Acoustics Alliance (HAA). Bob also serves as the technology editor for CE Pro's sister publication Commercial Integrator. In addition, he's studied guitar and music theory at Sarrin Music Studios in Wakefield, Mass., and he also studies Kyokushin karate at 5 Dragons in Haverhill, Mass. Have a suggestion or a topic you want to read more about? Email Robert at firstname.lastname@example.org
Follow Robert on social media:
Home TheaterCEDIA Expo Preview: LG on Big OLEDs, Short Throw Projectors, CI Focus
CEDIA Expo 2019 Sound Rooms Deliver Entertainment and Education
Product Briefs: Capitol Design Support; Elan adds Jandy; Crestron Marine Program; Zigbee Milestone
CEDIA Expo Preview: DPI Separates Light Engine, Electronics from Lens
Massive ADT Report Shows How Customers View Smart Home Tech
View more on Home Theater