Who Owns the Code? CE Industry’s Dirty Little Secret
When an integration company goes out of business, and customers don't have the programming code for their system, they can be left at the mercy of the bankruptcy courts.
NOTE: In my original story, as many have pointed out, I was completely unfair to Baumeister, a Chicago integration company that was forced to close its doors after many years of contributions to this industry. I have not heard Baumeister’s side of the story. I’m usually much better at giving the benefit of the doubt but in my haste to post this story in advance of the auction (ending today), I took too many liberties. I regret the insensitivity and am currently revising the story to talk about the important issues discussed here, rather than focusing on one of many integrators that has, sadly, gone out of business.
When you install a home control system, who owns the source code when the client is all paid up?
That’s a contentious issue in the industry, and no one seems to be talking about it.
The long-brewing issue, however, has become more urgent with the souring economy.
Some once-reputable integrators are going out of business and they’re taking their clients’ programming with them.
Consumers may be left with a lot of worthless equipment because no one else can take over a job without the source code.
This is a dirty little secret and it’s giving our industry a black eye.
What Happens When You Don’t have the Code?
Let’s say an integrator abruptly goes out of business and takes with it the Crestron code that was customized for each invidivual client.
Who Owns The Code?
 Who Owns the Code?
When Code Goes Missing
Without the source code, no other integrator—not even Crestron itself—can access a client’s system. That means that even the most basic changes to a system—say, swapping out a DVD player, adding another light switch, or changing a channel icon—cannot be made without starting from scratch.
Starting from scratch does not mean just programming the system from scratch. It means re-interviewing the clients, determining their preferences, learning how they live, and doing all those invasive things that the homeowner dreads.
Like they really want to go through it a second time?
It also means charting the subsystems, mapping out the wiring, troubleshooting, and so on and so on.
And then comes the programming. Potentially tens of thousands of dollars spent on the original programming could all be for naught.
Dave Haddad, president of Chicago-based Vidacom Corp., is a long-time critic of the “code-as-hostage” practice. He has taken over several jobs from Baumeister AV, an established, high-profile integration company that recently was forced to shut its doors.
Haddad estimates that he would have to charge one of the affected clients $50,000 “just to sort it all out,” he says.
And he is not rejoicing at that new-found business.
“Frankly, I’m embarrassed,” he says. “I wish I could buy all of that locked-up code and hand it out to the customers who put their faith in this industry.”
Julie Jacobson, recipient of the 2014 CEA TechHome Leadership Award, is co-founder of EH Publishing, producer of CE Pro, Electronic House, Commercial Integrator, Security Sales and other leading technology publications. She currently spends most of her time writing for CE Pro in the areas of home automation, security, networked A/V and the business of home systems integration. Julie majored in Economics at the University of Michigan, spent a year abroad at Cambridge University, earned an MBA from the University of Texas at Austin, and has never taken a journalism class in her life. She's a washed-up Ultimate Frisbee player currently residing in Carlsbad, Calif. Email Julie at [email protected]
NewsSavant Pro 8 Home Automation Software, Handheld Remote Now Shipping
Interview: B&W Acquired by Owner of San Francisco 49ers, a Super-Geeky Audiophile
PowerHouse Alliance to Host 25+ Training Events in May
EVA Automation Acquires Bowers & Wilkins (B&W)
Percentage of New Homes with Lighting Control Doubles Over 2 Years
View more News