Study Reveals Consumers Hate Home Automation Apps
Argus Insights study shows that consumers are frustrated with the user experience of many entry-level home automation apps. ADT, Philips, Comcast and AT&T systems in particular are dissed, while Vivint and Honeywell gain better marks.
A new study compiled by analyzing nearly 50,000 smart home device and app reviews reveals that consumers are extremely frustrated with entry-level home automation apps, noting that they often are “failing to delight” users. The data is great news for custom integrators who can offer their services to upsell more sophisticated home automation controls as a solution to the confusion that abounds.
According to Argus Insights, consumers are overall more frustrated with the applications that dictate, schedule and manage each device than with the actual devices themselves. Past Argus Insights reports looked at the hardware component and the challenges and irritations customers were experiencing with installation and connectivity, but this new analysis introduces a new data set to uncover the fact that consumers are experiencing even more issues with the apps that run these devices.
According to data compiled from nearly 50,000 Smart Home device and app reviews from August 2015 to the present, the incumbent home security companies like ADT, Comcast and AT&T are failing to delight consumers with their apps while the more innovative and newer smart home-focused companies like Vivint and Honeywell appear to be cultivating a more synchronized hardware and software ecosystem and are doing better among consumers.
“Companies that have aligned their entire ecosystem to delight consumers will outperform the rest of the market in the long term. Look how Honeywell came from behind to beat Nest with an overall better experience,” says John Feland, CEO and founder, Argus Insights.
Argus Insights found while software is very important in the consumer perception of the Smart Home experience, it is sometime very different from consumer perception of corresponding hardware. For example, Philips devices receive a higher delight score than Honeywell devices, but Honeywell’s apps are the most delightful according to the research, while Philips apps are the least liked. This scenario results in Honeywell providing a better overall experience across the entire smart home ecosystem, while Philips consumers report a foreboding gap in the experience between hardware and software.
“Companies like Philips must mind the gap between the devices and the experience of using the app,” says Dr. Feland. “Once consumers have installed and connected their device, the app becomes the primary touch point for their new Smart Home. Unfortunately, our analysis shows a looming lag in app experience which are a blemish on an otherwise improving end-to-end user experience.”
Argus Insights 2016: Vivint and Hneywell take the prize for delighting consumers.
